Last updated on July 6, 2023
Softball glove oil is a product that has been used for decades to help break in and maintain the quality of a softball glove. However, it’s totally understandable if you’re looking for a non-oily alternative that will save you time. There’s just a few things to keep in mind.
The most important thing to consider when choosing a softball glove oil alternative is the impact it will have on the glove’s performance. You want to choose a product that will not only condition the leather, but also provide the necessary grip and tackiness needed to catch a ball. Additionally, you want to choose a product that won’t damage the leather or cause it to break down over time.
There are several softball glove oil alternatives on the market, including balms, creams, and sprays. Each product has its own unique benefits and drawbacks, so let’s check them out.
Best Softball Glove Oil Alternatives
In this roundup, we’ve compiled a list of the best softball glove oil alternatives to help you keep your glove in top condition without the hassle.
Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner
If you want to keep your softball glove in tip-top shape, you should definitely consider the Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner. It is easy to apply and helps to soften and revitalize your glove, while also enhancing its color and restoring the natural leather scent.
Pros
- Easy to apply
- Softens and revitalizes glove
- Enhances color and restores natural leather scent
Cons
- May not work as well on extremely old or damaged gloves
- May require multiple applications for best results
- May leave a slightly greasy residue on the glove
If you’re looking for a glove conditioner that is easy to use and effective, the Wilson Pro Stock Glove Conditioner is definitely worth considering. It is easy to apply and helps to soften and revitalize your glove, while also enhancing its color and restoring the natural leather scent. However, it may not work as well on extremely old or damaged gloves, and may require multiple applications for best results. Additionally, it may leave a slightly greasy residue on the glove. Overall, though, it is a great product that can help extend the life of your softball glove.
Rawlings | Glove Conditioner | Baseball/Softball | Break-In Aid
If you’re looking for a reliable and easy-to-use glove conditioner, Rawlings Glove Conditioner is definitely worth considering. It’s one of the best options out there for treating and softening your glove, as well as restoring and giving new life to your old gloves.
Pros
- Softens, protects, and restores your leather ball gloves without adding weight
- Paste-based treatment ideal for baseball or softball gloves
- Easy to apply with cloth, sponge, or hands
Cons
- May not be as effective on gloves that are extremely dry or damaged
- Some users may find the paste-like consistency a bit messy to work with
- May take a little longer to fully break in your glove compared to some other products
Rawlings Glove Conditioner is a great choice if you want to keep your glove in top shape and extend its lifespan. It’s easy to apply and doesn’t add any unnecessary weight to your glove, making it ideal for players who want to maintain their equipment without compromising on performance. The paste-based treatment is also well-suited for both baseball and softball gloves, so you don’t have to worry about buying separate products for each sport.
One of the standout features of Rawlings Glove Conditioner is its ability to repel moisture from leather. This helps to keep your glove dry and prevent it from becoming stiff or damaged over time. Additionally, the conditioner serves as a break-in assistant, which means it can help soften the leather of your glove so it’s game-ready in no time.
While Rawlings Glove Conditioner may not be the best option for gloves that are extremely dry or damaged, it’s still a highly effective product for most players. It’s also relatively affordable, making it a great value for anyone who wants to keep their glove in top condition without breaking the bank.
Hot Glove Break-In Kit Value Bundle
If you’re looking for a quick and easy way to break in, weatherproof, and maintain your new softball glove, the Hot Glove Break-In Kit Value Bundle is a great choice.
Pros
- The Hot Glove Heat Treatment really works and breaks in new gloves in just 5 minutes.
- The Cream Conditioner is an all-natural waterproofing and conditioning cream that helps preserve and maintain your glove.
- The Wrap Bands and oversized waffle ball make it easy to maintain the pocket of your glove.
Cons
- The Heat Treatment can be a bit messy to apply and requires the use of an oven.
- The Cream Conditioner may leave a slightly greasy residue on your glove.
- The Wrap Bands may not fit all glove sizes and shapes.
The Hot Glove Break-In Kit Value Bundle includes everything you need to break in, weatherproof, and maintain your new softball glove. The Heat Treatment is easy to use, just foam it all over your glove, rub it in, and place in the oven for 5 minutes. Your glove will come out feeling soft and ready for play. After conditioning, place the ball in your glove pocket, and wrap glove with Hot Glove Wrap Bands. This will impress the pocket in the memory of the glove. Store glove with bands around it and ball inside the pocket to keep your glove in top shape. Overall, the Hot Glove Break-In Kit Value Bundle is a great investment if you want to keep your softball glove in top condition for years to come.
Covey Baseball Glove Breakin Kit
If you want to break in your new softball or baseball glove quickly and efficiently, the Covey Baseball Glove Breakin Kit is the perfect solution.
Pros
- The kit comes with everything you need to break in and maintain your glove, including a glove mallet, glove conditioning oil, glove wrap, and a microfiber cloth.
- The wooden mallet is durable and one-piece, so you don’t have to worry about the head coming off after repeated use.
- The glove wrap is perfect for holding the shape of your glove when it’s not in use, ensuring that it stays in top condition throughout the season.
Cons
- The kit may not be suitable for people who prefer to break in their gloves using traditional methods.
- The glove conditioning oil may not be suitable for people with allergies to lanolin, which is one of the ingredients.
- The kit may be more expensive than other glove conditioning products on the market.
The Covey Baseball Glove Breakin Kit is perfect for anyone who wants to break in their new softball or baseball glove quickly and efficiently. The kit comes with everything you need to soften and shape your glove, including a wooden mallet, glove conditioning oil, glove wrap, and a microfiber cloth. The mallet is durable and one-piece, so you don’t have to worry about the head coming off after repeated use. The glove wrap is perfect for holding the shape of your glove when it’s not in use, ensuring that it stays in top condition throughout the season. However, the kit may not be suitable for people who prefer to break in their gloves using traditional methods. Additionally, the glove conditioning oil may not be suitable for people with allergies to lanolin, which is one of the ingredients. Finally, the kit may be more expensive than other glove conditioning products on the market.
No Errors WebGem Fielder’s Glove Treatment The Twist
If you want to extend the life of your glove and keep it in top shape, the No Errors WebGem Fielder’s Glove Treatment The Twist is a great investment.
Pros
- Preserves glove shape and deepens pocket for added on-field performance
- Reduces new glove break-in time without a glove mallet
- Comes with a Neobreathe case that draws sweat from the glove to prevent moisture damage
Cons
- Pricey compared to other glove care products on the market
- May not fit all glove sizes
- Some users report that it doesn’t create the desired flare in smaller gloves
The No Errors WebGem Fielder’s Glove Treatment The Twist includes a glove forming tool, a Neobreathe case with removable handle wrap, two packs of glove conditioner, and a towel. The Flare creates a large vacuum to funnel the ball in, well suited for gloves up to 13″. Similar to that is The Flare XL, for gloves 13″ and above, exclusive to outfielders. The Roll gives a more tight feel to the glove, popular amongst pitchers and infielders, for gloves up to 11 3/4″. The Twist keeps the ball from dropping off the side, great for middle infielders and dominant pitchers with gloves up to 13″. The kit is designed to help you break into a new glove with ease or preserve your current one’s shape based on personal preference, increasing your glove’s life and usage and helping you save money in the long run.
If you’re serious about softball and want to keep your glove in top shape, the No Errors WebGem Fielder’s Glove Treatment The Twist is definitely worth considering. It’s a bit pricier than some other glove care products on the market, but the quality is top-notch and the included accessories make it a great value overall. The glove forming tool is easy to use and significantly reduces the break-in time of a new glove without a glove mallet, while the Neobreathe case and glove conditioner help to keep your glove in great shape for years to come. Just be sure to check the sizing before you buy to ensure that the kit will fit your glove properly.
Buying Guide
If you’re in the market for softball glove oil alternatives, it can be overwhelming to choose the best product. Here are some features to consider when making your decision:
Material
One of the most important things to consider when selecting a softball glove oil alternative is the material. Look for a product that is made from high-quality materials that will not damage your glove. Avoid products that contain harmful chemicals or substances that can cause your glove to break down over time.
Application
Another important factor to consider when choosing a softball glove oil alternative is the application process. Some products require you to rub the oil onto the glove, while others come in a spray bottle for easy application. Consider which method would be most convenient for you and choose a product accordingly.
Price
Price is always a consideration when making a purchase. While you don’t want to skimp on quality, you also don’t want to overspend. Look for a product that is reasonably priced and offers good value for your money.
Brand Reputation
Lastly, consider the reputation of the brand when choosing a softball glove oil alternative. Look for a brand that is known for producing high-quality products and has a good reputation among softball players. Reading reviews from other players can also help you make an informed decision.
| Features to Consider | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Material | High-quality materials that won’t damage your glove |
| Application | Easy-to-use method that suits your needs |
| Price | Reasonably priced and offers good value for your money |
| Brand Reputation | Well-known brand with a good reputation among softball players |
Softball Ace is THE online hub for all things softball. Since 2017, we’ve created insightful reviews on softball equipment like gloves and bats, but also provide fun and comprehensive education on softball culture, training tips, and softball-related advice.
