5 Reasons Leather Wins: The Ultimate Softball Glove Material Guide

Last updated on March 3, 2024

Looking for a new softball glove can be a daunting task. Factors such as the player’s age and position can help narrow down the search, but there are still plenty of other aspects to consider.

One of the most significant factors to consider when choosing a softball glove is the material it is made from. Gloves come in a variety of materials, each with its unique benefits and price points. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the different materials used in softball gloves and how they can impact your decision-making process.

Synthetics: Worth the trouble?

When it comes to softball gloves, synthetic materials have never been a popular choice among players. While these gloves may seem like a cheaper alternative to leather gloves, it’s important to remember that they’re cheaper for a reason. Synthetic gloves are essentially plastic and never get any more pliable than they are when purchased. This stiffness makes it difficult to close the glove and nearly impossible to break it in.

Synthetic gloves also have a shorter lifespan than leather gloves because the stitching materials degrade quickly. They rarely last more than a season or two. The cost of repeatedly replacing a synthetic glove can quickly add up to – or even surpass – the cost of a leather glove.

When to Consider a Synthetic Glove

If you have a very young player, such as a tee-ball age child, a synthetic glove may seem reasonable because they will quickly outgrow it. Additionally, if money is tight, the low price of a synthetic glove may seem attractive. My youngest daughter is playing in tee-ball and I have her using a synthetic glove purely because it’s much easier to squeeze.

Leather: The Choice of Serious Players

When it comes to softball gloves, leather is the preferred material for serious players. The reason for this is simple: leather gloves offer a custom fit and durability that synthetic gloves cannot match. Once broken in, leather becomes soft and pliable, which feels great. Its durability means it provides protection and longevity that synthetics don’t come close to. If properly cared for, a leather softball glove will last many seasons.

There are several types of leather used in softball gloves, each with its own unique properties and price points. Let’s take a closer look at some of the most common options:

Full-Grain Leather

Full-grain leather is lightweight, making it good for younger players. It’s cowhide that hasn’t been subjected to any processing, like sanding. The “grain” of the leather is permeable and allows it to absorb conditioners, letting it stretch and form around your hand. You can find full-grain leather gloves pre-conditioned with oils, or you can find them in their natural state. Cowhide isn’t as durable as the other options, so

Steer Hide

Another common choice for leather gloves, which is slightly more affordable, is steer hide. This leather is thicker and its grain is courser, allowing more conditioning agents into the material. Its added weight might be a drawback to a younger player, but it makes the glove extremely durable. It’s an excellent option for players who want their gloves broken in a specific way. However, that durability comes at the cost of a longer break-in period.

Calfskin

Calfskin, or kip, is the most popular choice among professionals. This leather is thinner and lighter than steer and full-grain leather, with a tighter grain. This combination makes for a softer material, but one that is still breathable and tough. It is also easier to break in than the other options, and will be ready for play soon after it is purchased.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do weather conditions affect the choice of glove material?

Weather conditions shouldn’t significantly influence the choice of glove material. With that in mind, leather gloves may become stiff and harder to shut in cold weather. Synthetic gloves are less affected by moisture and temperature changes, making them a good choice in more humid or rainy climates. However, leather gloves, if properly cared for, offer a level of comfort and performance that synthetic materials struggle to match, making them the preferred softball glove material choice for serious players regardless of weather conditions.

How does the stitching quality affect the durability and performance of softball gloves?

The quality of stitching in a softball glove plays a crucial role in its durability. High-quality stitching ensures that the glove holds together under the stress of catching high-speed balls, reducing the likelihood of tears or separations between the glove’s parts. Gloves with poor stitching can quickly fall apart or lose their shape.

Are there specific brands known for their superior leather or synthetic gloves?

A handful of elite brands stand out for crafting top-tier leather and synthetic softball gloves, with Wilson, Rawlings, and Mizuno leading the pack. Among their offerings, Wilson’s A2000 series, Rawlings’ Heart of the Hide, and Mizuno’s Pro Select models are known for their exceptional quality.


Leave a Comment