5 of the Most Expensive Softball Gloves That Are Totally Worth It

Last updated on April 3, 2023

Softball is a popular sport enjoyed by people of all ages and skill levels. A key component in a player’s gear is the softball glove, which is instrumental in catching and fielding the ball. Specifically designed for softball, these gloves provide a secure and comfortable fit while offering increased flexibility and control when making plays. With the vast array of gloves available on the market, finding a high-quality glove for your needs can be an investment in your performance on the field.

softball catcher

If you’re thinking about buying an expensive softball glove, it’s essential to pay attention to certain factors such as the glove’s material, size, weight, and craftsmanship. High-quality materials, such as premium leather, can contribute to the overall durability and comfort of the glove. The right size and fit are also crucial, as they ensure optimal performance and reduced risk of injury. Lastly, the craftsmanship that goes into making the glove can ultimately determine its longevity and ability to withstand the rigors of the game.

With so many freakin’ options, navigating the world of softball gloves can be overwhelming. Have no fear, because we’re here to help you make an informed decision for your next big investment.

Glove NameBrandMaterialSizeBreak-In PeriodWebbing Type
Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball GloveRawlingsFull-grain leather12.5″80% factory break-inBasket web
Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Baseball GloveRawlingsHeart of the Hide steer leather12.5″Minimal break-in timePro H web
Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball GloveRawlingsFull-grain leather12.5″Needs break-in periodSingle post web
WILSON 2022 A2000 Fastpitch Softball GloveWilsonPro Stock Leather12″Long break-in period requiredDual post web
Franklin Sports Fastpitch Windmill 12″ GloveFranklin SportsLightweight mesh12″Short break-in periodClosed web

Most Expensive Softball Gloves

Let’s start off with one of the old stalwarts of softball, Rawlings.

1) Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove

Rawlings' all new R9 Series fastpitch gloves

The Rawlings R9 Fastpitch Softball Glove is a top-quality option for players seeking an excellent performance glove with outstanding durability and comfort.


  • High-quality full-grain leather construction
  • 80% factory break-in for quick game-ready feel
  • Adjustable pull-strap closures for personalized fit and performance


  • May not be suitable for younger players
  • Some users might prefer more padding in the palm

I can’t say enough good things about its performance on the field. The soft, durable all-leather shell ensures a game-ready feel from the moment you put it on. Even more impressive is the 80% factory break-in, making the glove virtually ready to use straight out of the box.

The adjustable pull-strap closures cater to players with different hand sizes and provide a snug, comfortable fit during gameplay. While the cushioned palm padding does offer a good level of impact protection, I noticed that some users might prefer a little more padding, especially when catching hard-thrown balls.

One downside to consider is that the Rawlings R9 is on the expensive side in comparison to other gloves on the market. However, with its outstanding features and construction, I believe it’s well worth the investment for serious softball players who value performance, durability, and a comfortable fit.

1) Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Baseball Glove

Rawlings' all new Heart of the Hide R2G gloves

Invest in this top-notch Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Baseball Glove for an elite, comfortable, and durable experience on the field.


  • Game-ready feel with minimal break-in time
  • Narrow fit design perfect for smaller hands
  • Constructed from high-quality Heart of the Hide steer leather


  • Pricey option for a softball glove
  • May require additional break-in for younger players
  • Heavier than some competing gloves

Playing with the Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Baseball Glove has been a game-changer. Right off the bat, it provides an almost game-ready feel with very little break-in needed. For players with smaller hands, this glove has a tailored narrow fit design which enhances grip and control. There’s a reason this glove is constructed from Rawlings’ world-renowned Heart of the Hide steer leather – it ensures absolute top-tier quality and performance.

However, it’s essential to keep in mind that the investment in this glove is not exactly budget-friendly. While the craftsmanship and materials make it worth the price for serious players, it might not fit everyone’s budget. Additionally, although the glove comes partially broken in, younger players with less strength may still find the break-in process a bit challenging.

Lastly, the superior Heart of the Hide leather does make the glove heavier than some competitors. However, don’t let that discourage you – the exceptional durability, comfort, and performance that the Rawlings Heart of the Hide R2G Baseball Glove offers will undoubtedly elevate your game to new heights.

1) Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove

Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove

Get your hands on the Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove for an exceptional first base playing experience with premium quality and comfort.


  • Durable full-grain leather construction
  • Optimized for first base players
  • Perfect for high school to pro players


  • Needs break-in period
  • Not suitable for all playing positions

This glove is crafted with top-notch full-grain leather, making it a durable and comfortable option for avid softball players.

The Liberty Advanced Glove is designed specifically for first base players. Using the glove, you can stretch, scoop, and field throws with ease, building your confidence on the field. It has adjustable pull-strap closures that help you find the perfect fit for your hand, ensuring a reliable and secure hold.

One thing to note is that it needs some break-in time, but considering its excellent performance after that, it’s worth the effort. Overall, if you’re a first base player looking for a high-end softball glove, the Rawlings Liberty Advanced Fastpitch Softball Glove is a fantastic choice.

1) WILSON 2022 A2000 Fastpitch Softball Glove

WILSON 2022 A2000 Fastpitch Softball Glove

The WILSON 2022 A2000 Fastpitch Softball Glove offers top-of-the-line performance and quality, ideal for serious players looking for the most expensive softball gloves.


  • Excellent support and shape retention with Rolled Dual Welting
  • Flat Finger Binding for comfort and control
  • Pro Stock Leather offers durability and unmatched feel


  • Long break-in period required
  • May feel heavy to some users
  • Pricey for beginners or casual players

Using the WILSON 2022 A2000 Fastpitch Softball Glove feels like a dream thanks to its Pro Stock Leather material that offers a unique combination of rugged durability and an incredible feel. Furthermore, the glove comes with DriLex Wrist Lining that keeps your hand dry and comfortable on the field, making it a game-changer.

Designed with Rolled Dual Welting, the glove provides better support and holds its shape better over time, giving you the confidence to make those crucial plays. The Flat Finger Binding feature is especially great for players who prefer a finger outside the glove, as it offers extra comfort and control in the field.

However, the glove does come with its drawbacks, such as a longer break-in period, which might not be suitable for everyone. Additionally, some users may find the glove a bit heavier than other options, so it may take some time to adjust. Finally, being a top-notch glove targeted at serious players, the price might not be feasible for beginners or casual softball enthusiasts.

1) Franklin Sports Fastpitch Windmill 12″ Glove

Franklin Sports Windmill Series Fastpitch Pro Softball glove

If you’re seeking a high-performance and comfortable softball glove, the Franklin Sports Windmill 12″ Glove is a top contender with its lightweight mesh design and adjustable fit.


  • Lightweight, technical mesh construction
  • Adjustable wrist closure for customized fit
  • Soft pocket material for quick break-in


  • Not made of genuine leather
  • May not suit advanced players
  • Stiffness requires initial break-in

Having recently tried out the Franklin Sports Fastpitch Windmill 12″ Glove, I can attest to the glove’s lightweight feel and exceptional comfort. The technical mesh design ensures easy maneuvering, while the adjustable wrist closure creates a secure, personalized fit for any player.

The soft pocket material is a welcome feature, allowing for a swift and painless break-in process. Catching the ball feels responsive and dynamic, making it an excellent glove for young players or those new to softball. However, advanced players may find the lack of genuine leather a downside, as it may not provide the same durability and performance as leather gloves.

It’s important to note that the glove can be stiff upon arrival, so be prepared for a short break-in period. Once broken in, the Franklin Sports Fastpitch Windmill 12″ Glove offers remarkable ease of use and performance, making it a valuable investment for any softball player seeking a high-quality, comfortable glove.

Buying Guide

When looking for the most expensive softball gloves, it’s essential to consider more than just the price. High-quality gloves should have features that improve performance and ensure a good fit. In this section, we’ll discuss factors that you should consider when purchasing a top-of-the-line softball glove.


Materials used in manufacturing gloves play a crucial role in their overall durability and performance. The most common materials for high-end gloves include:

  • Full-grain leather
  • Steerhide
  • Japanese-tanned Kip leather

These materials offer superb durability, often molding well to the player’s hand over time.

Size and Fit

Another essential factor is choosing the right size and fit for your glove. Softball gloves come in a variety of sizes, typically ranging from 9 to 15 inches. To find your ideal fit, measure from the base of your palm to the tip of your index finger. Remember that a snug, secure fit will prevent the glove from slipping or causing discomfort.

Break-In Period

High-quality softball gloves typically require a break-in period to conform to the shape of your hand. Some gloves come pre-broken in, while others might take more time to achieve the desired comfort and flexibility. Be prepared to spend some time working with your glove before it reaches peak performance.

Webbing and Pocket

The webbing and pocket design of a softball glove can impact how well you catch and secure the ball. Consider the following factors:

Webbing TypeDescription
Open WebOffers better visibility and tends to be lighter
Closed WebProvides more support and cushioning, ideal for pitchers

The pocket should be deep enough to securely hold the ball while not being too deep, which can make it difficult to retrieve the ball quickly.

Final Thoughts

Investing in a high-quality softball glove can significantly improve your performance on the field. The most expensive softball gloves offer superior materials, a comfortable fit, and excellent craftsmanship. When choosing a glove, consider factors such as the material, size and fit, break-in period, and webbing and pocket design. Remember, a great glove is not just an expense, but an investment in your success on the field.

Leave a Comment